The books Southern indie booksellers are recommending to readers everywhere!

Horror

I’ll Make a Spectacle of You by Beatrice Winifred Iker

With its ominous wood setting and perfect lingering dread, this debut gothic horror comes just in time for dark autumn nights. The drama and plot are excellent. There were many surprises, and the ending shocked me. The protagonist, Zora, is among my favorite heroines of the year!

I’ll Make a Spectacle of You by Beatrice Winifred Iker, (List Price: $19.99, Run For It, 9780316575249, November 2025)

Reviewed by Sandra Pinkney, The Underground Bookshop in Carrollton, Georgia

I’ll Make a Spectacle of You by Beatrice Winifred Iker Read More »

A Box Full of Darkness by Simone St. James

Simone St. James is the queen of writing supernatural thrillers. This one is told from three siblings’ points of view, and them going back to their home where their brother mysteriously disappeared years ago. It’s time to find out what really happened to him. While reading this, we get snippets about each of the siblings’ lives and how they interconnect, along with how their upbringing led them to where they are now. Their interactions could be humorous, and it was interesting how they each knew a reveal or found something out in a unique way that brought the story to justice. You’ll get the perfect amount of creepiness from this story! If you’ve read any Simone St. James book, you’ll find a ton of Easter eggs and nods to her other books in this one, especially since this one takes place in the same town as the Sundown Motel! Such a fun read that I didn’t want to put down!

A Box Full of Darkness by Simone St. James, (List Price: $30, Berkley, 9780593200414, January 2026)

Reviewed by Brooke, Spellbound Bookstore in Sanford, Florida

A Box Full of Darkness by Simone St. James Read More »

A Box Full of Darkness by Simone St. James

Honey, the land!” No spoilers, but Simone St. James has really outdone herself with this twisty supernatural mystery/thriller. Every overturned stone along the plot’s path is captivating, and I never wanted to put it down. I love the sibling dynamics as they return to their haunted childhood home in search of answers regarding their little brother, who went missing at just 6 years old. The Broken Girls may still be my favorite, but this is a very close second.

A Box Full of Darkness by Simone St. James, (List Price: $30, Berkley, 9780593200414, January 2026)

Reviewed by Jenny Ford, Bookmarks in Winston-Salem, North Carolina

A Box Full of Darkness by Simone St. James Read More »

The Weight of Blood by Tiffany D. Jackson

Jackson really gets better with every book! I was hooked from page one on this updated version of Carrie, and I think Stephen King would be proud to have inspired this. Maddy is biracial and outcast from her peers and miserable at home with her abusive father. Racial tensions dividing the town of Springville come to a head on prom night, and the results are…explosive. Do not miss this amazing YA thriller!

The Weight of Blood by Tiffany D. Jackson, (List Price: $15.95, Quill Tree Books, 9780063029156, September 2023)

Reviewed by Andrea Richardson, Fountain Bookstore in Richmond, Virginia

The Weight of Blood by Tiffany D. Jackson Read More »

Final Cut by Olivia Worley

I LOVE Louisiana-set stories when the author knows things about Louisiana, and I especially love them when the author is from Louisiana. This YA thriller is wonderfully done from setting to plot. Oliva does a wonderful job at the misdirection, and I truly had no clue who the murderer was until it was revealed. This is a top-tier YA thriller that anyone should pick up!

Final Cut by Olivia Worley, (List Price: $21, Wednesday Books, 9781250392985, October 2025)

Reviewed by sarah dimaria, Cavalier House Books in Denham Springs, Louisiana

Final Cut by Olivia Worley Read More »

Vampires at Sea by Lindsay Merbaum

What happens when your lover burns your immortal beloved’s art? You go on vacation to rekindle the flame (and hunt, obviously). Join Rebekah and Hugh as they navigate the emotional depths of a queer cruise and realize that they aren’t the only ones hunting. Merbaum’s storytelling perfectly captures the essence of ‘We’re on Vacation’ mode. Full of humor, glamour, and orgies, Vampires at Sea will expose the longevity of being an immortal in love.

Vampires at Sea by Lindsay Merbaum, (List Price: $18, Creature Publishing, 9781951971229, October 2025)

Reviewed by Jenny Gilroy, E. Shaver Bookseller in Savannah, Georgia

Vampires at Sea by Lindsay Merbaum Read More »

Ghost Circus by Adrienne Kress, Jade Zhang (Illus.)

Ghost Circus has beautiful illustrations! I loved the characters in the Circus and I hope we see more of the creepy girl and find out more about her and her memories! I am also super excited her friend Casey gets to come back and see her more and they can uncover more of the mystery of the creepy girl!

Ghost Circus by Adrienne Kress, Jade Zhang (Illus.), (List Price: $24.99, Union Square Kids, 9781454948285, August 2025)

Reviewed by sarah dimaria, Cavalier House Books in Denham Springs, Louisiana

Ghost Circus by Adrienne Kress, Jade Zhang (Illus.) Read More »

Hazelthorn by CG Drews

Perfect! Five stars! Hazelthorn is my all-time favorite YA and horror book, and I highly recommend it! The romance is fantastic, and the world-building and eerie gothic atmosphere are amazing! The protagonist, Evander, who tragically loses his parents and is adopted by a reclusive billionaire who imprisons him in his room like a prisoner, instantly won my heart. Following the suspicious death of the billionaire, estranged families bring in a new attorney to carry out the will, and Evander is compelled to form an alliance with Laurie, his sworn enemy. The two learn secret information about the forbidden garden, the sinister red door, and the enigmatic mansion. Evander discovers he is drawn to Laurie in unexpected ways. The conclusion will never be forgotten! By the way, I can never look at plants the same way again.

Hazelthorn by CG Drews, (List Price: $19.99, Feiwel & Friends, 9781250376299, October 2025)

Reviewed by Sandra Pinkney, The Underground Bookshop LLC in Carrollton, Georgia

Hazelthorn by CG Drews Read More »

What Stalks the Deep by T. Kingfisher

It’s all the bests of the Sworn Soldier series — looming dread, compelling narration, and a touch of wry humor — now paired with the Appalachian Gothic. What Stalks the Deep follows Alex Easton deep into a West Virginian coal mine of twisting tunnels, disappearances, and eldritch creatures lurking in the depths.

What Stalks the Deep by T. Kingfisher, (List Price: $19.99, Tor Nightfire, 9781250354921, September 2025)

Reviewed by Flora Arnsberger, Epilogue: Books Chocolate Brews in Chapel Hill, North Carolina

What Stalks the Deep by T. Kingfisher Read More »

You Weren’t Meant to Be Human by Andrew Joseph White

You Weren’t Meant to Be Human by Andrew Joseph White is a rollercoaster of raw, unsettling, and yet, beautiful human emotions. This is White’s first adult horror novel and please be warned, this book is scary as hell. Crane is a mute, autistic, trans man, who has been assisting in the invasion of an alien infestation known as “the Hive”. When Crane suddenly finds out he is pregnant and the Hive demands the birth of the child at all costs, Crane’s resistance and desperation to end the pregnancy sets off a series of events that cause a whirlwind of panic, anger, and violence that no one could have anticipated. Andrew Joseph White has literally taken the rough and gritty underbelly of small town gas station, added literal piles of “worms and flies” or “the Hive” and created one of the scariest settings I’ve read in a long time. White has a natural way of writing body horror that pushes every boundary and deliberately disturbs the reader with stomach-twisting imagery. The book will have readers truly gasping and screaming all the way toward the very last page. (No joke, I had a truly visceral feeling of horror upon finishing the book.) If you are a fan of anxiety-inducing films like Hereditary (2018) and Midsommar (2019) and also love a good gory Alien (1979) movie, you have to check out “You Weren’t Meant to Be Human by Andrew Joseph White when it releases on September 9, 2025.

You Weren’t Meant to Be Human by Andrew Joseph White, (List Price: $29, S&S/Saga Press, 9781668038079, September 2025)

Reviewed by Baldwin Bookseller, Baldwin & Co. in New Orleans, Louisiana

You Weren’t Meant to Be Human by Andrew Joseph White Read More »

A Spell to Wake the Dead by Nicole Lesperance

Witchcraft, ghosts, cults, and romance! I was stressed out at every turn, worried about this teen friend group’s safety and sanity.

A Spell to Wake the Dead by Nicole Lesperance, (List Price: $19.99, G.P. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers, 9780593856338, August 2025)

Reviewed by Eden Haymon, Cavalier House Books in Denham Springs, Louisiana

A Spell to Wake the Dead by Nicole Lesperance Read More »

Lucky Day by Chuck Tingle

Lucky Day is a ROLLER COASTER. An existential CRISIS. A foray through the blood and guts of reality itself to the abyss at the heart of it all, where you just have to ask yourself one question: “Do I feel lucky?” Well? Do ya? •••••• I loved this scifi-heavy romp of a story where the true horror is existence itself. Or is it? Chuck Tingle weaves an intricate web of sharp nihilism, absurdity, and genuinely creepy moments, building a structure upon which rests the ultimate truth: life is chaos, and existence is precious. I laughed, I shuddered, I cried. I finished this book at 2:00 a.m. this morning and am still processing all its truths. In fact, I’ll be thinking about it for a very long time. 5/5 stars, 10/10 recommend.

Lucky Day by Chuck Tingle, (List Price: $27.99, Tor Nightfire, 9781250398659, August 2025)

Reviewed by Rachel Derise, Pearl’s Books in Fayetteville, Arkansas

Lucky Day by Chuck Tingle Read More »

One Yellow Eye by Leigh Radford

This was a fresh take on zombie horror. While zombies have been eradicated, the main character has chosen to secretly harbor her zombie husband in her apartment. As you can imagine, this does not go well! I loved the exploration of what the main character would do for her partner.

One Yellow Eye by Leigh Radford, (List Price: $28.99, Gallery Books, 9781668081211, July 2025)

Reviewed by Jackie Davison, The Lynx in Gainesville, Florida

One Yellow Eye by Leigh Radford Read More »

Freakslaw by Jane Flett

A roiling and intense debut featuring an untamable traveling freak show and the small, narrow-minded Scottish town it invades. What follows are unpredictable celebrations of freakishness, intoxicating forays into carnivals unknown, and the flickering flames of brutality. A furious mob is looming. Which side will you be on?

Freakslaw by Jane Flett, (List Price: $28, Zando, 9781638932666, April 2025)

Reviewed by Joshua Lambie, Underground Books in Carrollton, Georgia

Freakslaw by Jane Flett Read More »

Polybius by Collin Armstrong

Definitely reminded me of all of those cult classic 80’s horror movies. I figured out some things earlier than the characters did, but I was hooked to the end, wanting to find out what happens. Would recommend to booksellers, co-workers, friends and family.

Polybius by Collin Armstrong, (List Price: $28.99, Gallery Books, 9781668044971, April 2025)

Reviewed by Stacey Schwartz, Murder On the Beach Mystery Bookstore in Delray Beach, Florida

Polybius by Collin Armstrong Read More »

Scroll to Top